OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts in Collision Repair: What's the Difference

When you bring your New Albany daily driver in for repairs after a collision, you’ll have two choices for replacement parts: OEM and aftermarket. If you’ve recently been in an accident, Byers Collision Center is comparing OEM vs. aftermarket parts to help you decide which is the best option for your situation. If you still have questions after reading, call (866) 272-9556 to get in touch with our certified technicians for further assistance.

OEM Parts

Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts are engineered by the automaker and often the same parts that came with your vehicle when it rolled off the assembly line. OEM parts offer peace of mind on the Pickerington roads, but that comes at a higher cost. Here are a few benefits and disadvantages of buying OEM vs. aftermarket car parts:

Pros

• Quality: OEM parts are designed specifically for your vehicle model, ensuring a perfect fit and alignment.
• Safety: OEM replacement parts meet stringent standards set by the manufacturer. For example, while an OEM vs. aftermarket windshield may seem insignificant, it can potentially impact the overall safety and performance of your vehicle.
• Warranty: OEM parts often come with a warranty to protect you if the part is defective or doesn’t work properly.

Cons

• Higher cost: OEM parts generally cost more than aftermarket parts because of their superior quality.
• Limited availability: High demand for OEM parts can result in limited stock, causing longer ordering times and delays in restocking.

Aftermarket Parts

Aftermarket parts are not sourced from the automaker and are usually designed to be compatible with many makes and models. That said, many drivers often question whether these parts are a better choice. To help clarify this, here are some important considerations when comparing aftermarket vs. OEM replacements:

Pros

• Affordability: Aftermarket parts are generally less expensive than OEM replacements, which can be a significant factor for those on a budget.
• Variety: Aftermarket parts can be made by any company that wants to manufacture car parts, so you have more options when looking for a part.

Cons

• Quality: Car manufacturers do not oversee the quality of aftermarket parts, so there’s no guarantee that the part will work well or even fit your car correctly.
• Warranty: Most aftermarket parts have limited warranties or no warranty at all, which means you’re out more money if the part is defective or doesn’t fit.
• Lower Resale Value: Using OEM parts for repairs and maintenance helps preserve your vehicle’s resale value. This means the choice between an OEM vs. aftermarket windshield can be a crucial factor if you plan to sell your car in the future.

OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to collision repairs, choosing between aftermarket vs. OEM is ultimately a personal decision. The debate of OEM vs. aftermarket car parts often revolves around cost, quality, and your vehicle’s needs. Generally, though, aftermarket parts can be a great option for customization or upgrades. However, for critical repairs, it is advisable to use OEM parts to ensure optimal safety and reliability. It is important to note, however, that insurance companies tend to prefer aftermarket parts due to the cost savings. So in some cases, your insurance company may require you to pay the difference if you request OEM parts for your repair.

Deciding between OEM vs. aftermarket car parts can be a tough choice, but at Byers Collision Center, our technicians will carefully assess various factors and provide personalized recommendations on the best type of part for your specific needs.

Visit Our Parts & Service Center in Columbus

When you’re considering an OEM vs. aftermarket windshield or other replacement parts, it’s crucial to consult with a professional to ensure you’re making the best choice for your vehicle. At Byers Collision Center, we stand behind our work, whether you choose aftermarket vs. OEM parts, and want you to feel confident in trusting us with your collision repair. Schedule an appointment at our service center today or stop by our parts center near Gahanna to get more information. While you’re here, don’t miss out on our other service tips and maintenance guides put together by our team of experts.